Exploring Culture-Bound Therapy: How Culture Shapes Mental Health

Everyone seems to need a therapist these days—at least, that’s the trending idea among modern WEIRD (Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic) societies.

Understanding yourself is like understanding a country—you sometimes need to look from the outside in. That perspective can come through meditation, psychedelics, travel, social bonds (which we explored last week), and yes, therapy.

But are therapists always the best option? Critics argue they can be sales-driven, “need therapy themselves,” or create dependency. While therapy often teaches techniques for self-reliance, those techniques don’t always translate across cultures. What heals in one culture may harm in another.

The Globalization of Western Therapy

In Crazy Like Us: The Globalization of the American Psyche, Ethan Watters argues that exporting Western mental health treatments globally often produces ineffective—or even harmful—outcomes.

For example:

• Anorexia in Hong Kong – The condition didn’t manifest in its Western form until recently, when psychiatrists began interpreting local symptoms through a Western lens.
• PTSD in Sri Lanka – After the 2004 tsunami, locals didn’t commonly report PTSD until Western aid workers introduced the concept, inadvertently shaping how trauma was understood.

As historian Edward Shorter explains:

“Each culture provides a ‘symptom pool’ of recognized and discussed symptoms. People express inner conflicts in a language shaped by that pool. When given new conceptions of mental illness, they may adopt those new symptoms.”

This makes it vital to recognize how healing practices differ worldwide before applying a one-size-fits-all therapeutic model.

Western Psychotherapy: From Freud to CBT

Western psychotherapy traces its roots to Sigmund Freud, who developed psychoanalysis in the late 19th century. Freud argued that unconscious conflicts drive psychological struggles and that exploring memories in individual sessions could resolve them (though some interpretations—like boys wanting to replace their fathers—deserve a quick move along).

By the 20th century, Carl Rogers reshaped psychoanalysis into a client-centered approach that emphasized self-discovery. From there, numerous schools of therapy emerged, the most common being cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)—a method focused on reframing thoughts and managing reactions through controlled exposure.

Alongside these approaches, psychiatry increasingly emphasized biological explanations for mental illness. Despite their variety, Western therapies often rely on clients’ ability to articulate struggles in ways shaped by Western cultural norms.

Indigenous Healing Practices: Family and Spiritualism

In many cultures, therapy looks very different. A cross-cultural study of 16 societies in Africa, Asia, South America, the Middle East, and the Caribbean revealed two dominant models of healing:

1. Family as the healer – In many societies, family members (especially elders) play a central role in resolving mental health challenges. For example, in Saudi Arabia, families often hide mental illness due to stigma until the problem becomes unmanageable, at which point they may seek help from extended kin or community.
2. Spiritualism and religion – Mental illness is often seen as rooted in spiritual imbalance. Traditional healers like shamans lead treatment rituals. Among the Yoruba of West Africa, for instance, mental distress is explained through disruptions in relationships with gods. Healing involves divination to restore balance among body (ara), mind (emi), and inner head (ori).

While these approaches may not resonate with everyone (I admit, spiritualism wouldn’t work for me), they show how different cultures frame mental health and healing.

Japanese Therapies: Morita and Naikan

Even among developed nations, psychotherapies vary. Japan offers two notable alternatives:

• Morita therapy – Designed for anxiety and depression, it emphasizes acceptance rather than symptom elimination. Clients engage in bed rest, manual labor, meditation, and guided reflection to learn how to live productively with symptoms.
• Naikan therapy – Focused on gratitude and reflection, it asks clients to revisit their past—particularly childhood—and recognize kindness received from others, often their mothers. This therapy reframes the past through gratitude and guilt, offering new meaning.

Both approaches differ from Western models, showing how culture profoundly shapes the therapeutic process.

Why Cultural Competence in Therapy Matters

Given cultural diversity, should therapists always match clients of the same background? Research shows benefits—shared language, deeper understanding—but also risks, such as “ghettoizing” therapists from certain groups.

As a third-culture kid, I’ve found my greatest mental health growth through travel therapy—sharing stories with people outside my cultural frame. Sometimes, talking less about “trauma” and more about universal human experiences feels more healing than formal therapy.

Still, cultural competence is crucial. Therapists working across cultures must:

1. Recognize their own cultural lens – Understand how personal background shapes interpretations.
2. Learn about clients’ cultures – Anticipate expectations and communication styles.
3. Develop relevant skills – Intervene in culturally sensitive ways while balancing individual needs with cultural context.

Because every client engages with culture uniquely, therapists must remain flexible, especially when working with people navigating multiple cultural identities.

Cultural Consultation Services

How can therapists strengthen their cross-cultural expertise? One answer is cultural consultation services—teams of psychiatrists, psychologists, anthropologists, interpreters, and culture brokers who advise on multicultural cases. These teams address complex issues such as migration stress, family systems, cultural identity, and trauma from war or torture.

Of course, such services are often expensive and inaccessible. But here at Born Without Borders, you gain access to these kinds of insights at a fraction of the cost—simply by subscribing.

Key Takeaway: Culture-bound therapy reminds us that mental health isn’t universal. Healing depends not just on methods, but on the cultural lens through which those methods are understood.

If you believe in research and writing that break down borders, foster cross-cultural understanding, and inspire people to live unbound, consider becoming a paid subscriber to Born Without Borders.
All my work is published on Ghost, a decentralized, non-profit, and carbon-neutral platform—free from VC funding and the grip of technofeudal lords.
I don’t use algorithms to hijack your attention.
My work can only exist if you share and support it.

• Become a Paid Member: Get access to all exclusive content and potentially included access to certain courses/workshops and directly support this work for just $5/ month or $50 / year.
• Become a Founding Member: For those who want to make sure I stay off the platforms causing mental illness, polarization, and a technofeudal shit show. Your deeper support makes all the difference for $30/ month or $300 / year.

Need Specialized Coaching?

• Unlock Your Authentic Voice (Across Cultures & Systems): If you're a multilingual professional or "cultural inbetweener" who feels unseen or misread, let's refine your English for nuance, confidence, and true self-expression.

Affiliate Links for Global Citizens

• Home Exchange: Trade homes, not hotel bills. Live like a local anywhere in the world.
• Wise: Send money across borders without losing your mind (or half your paycheck in fees).
• Preply: Make a living teaching people worldwide.
• Flatio: A more ethical version of Airbnb.